White Hat Harbor

How to price baked goods

To price a box of cookies or a cake, you need what one batch costs in ingredients, how many pieces it makes, your time, the packaging, a share of your monthly costs and, if you sell on Etsy, the fees taken from each sale. This page shows how to cost a recipe from what you pay for each bag and carton, how to solve for a price that keeps your margin, and works a dozen cookies through. It's the method my Recipe Cost & Bakery Pricing Calculator spreadsheet uses.

Etsy's fees here are its US rates for sellers using Etsy Payments as of 26 October 2026. Rates differ by country and change from time to time: check Etsy's Fees & Payments Policy for your shop.

Ingredient cost per recipe

You buy flour by the 5 lb bag and measure it by the cup, so each line of a recipe needs converting into the unit you buy in:

  1. Cost per pack unit = pack price ÷ pack size. A 5 lb bag at $4.29 is $0.858 a pound; a dozen eggs at $3.49 is $0.29 an egg.
  2. Convert the recipe amount. Volume to volume and weight to weight is a fixed factor (1 cup = 16 tbsp = 48 tsp = 236.6 ml; 1 lb = 16 oz = 453.6 g). Volume to weight needs the ingredient's grams per cup, because a cup of flour weighs much less than a cup of sugar. Common figures are about 120 g for all-purpose flour, 200 g for granulated sugar and 227 g for butter; weigh a level cup of your own for the best number.
  3. Line cost = the amount in pack units × the cost per pack unit. Add the lines up for the batch cost.

From the batch to what you sell

Cost per packHow to work it out
IngredientsBatch cost ÷ pieces the batch makes × pieces in what you sell (12 for a dozen)
LabourMinutes per batch (mixing, baking, decorating, cleanup) ÷ 60 × your hourly rate, shared the same way over the packs the batch makes
PackagingBox, bag, liner, ribbon, label
OverheadMonthly costs you pay whatever you sell (a share of kitchen power, insurance, permits, labels) ÷ the packs you expect to sell a month

Count your time as a cost, like the butter. A price that only covers ingredients pays you nothing for the afternoon.

Etsy's fees on one sale

FeeUS rateCharged on
Transaction fee6.5%The item price plus the shipping you charge (and gift wrap)
Payment processing3% + $0.25The order total, sales tax included
Listing fee$0.20When you list, again each time the item sells (the listing renews), and every 4 months it stays unsold
Offsite Ads15%, or 12% once a shop has made $10,000 in a yearOnly orders Etsy credits to one of its ads on other sites, up to $100 an order. Shops under $10,000 a year can opt out.
Etsy AdsYour own budgetOptional. For pricing, count it as a share of your sales.

Fees are charged on shipping too, and baked goods ship fast and padded, so postage is often one of the biggest numbers in the sale. Processing on sales tax is left out of the formulas below; it's small, and it's charged on money that isn't yours.

Solve for the price

Margin here means profit ÷ (price + shipping you charge), where profit is what's left after every cost, the postage you pay, Etsy's fees and your ads. Fees are a share of the price, so work backwards from the margin you want:

Lowest price + shipping charged = (cost per pack + postage + $0.25 + $0.20) ÷ (1 − 6.5% − 3% − Etsy Ads % − share of orders from Offsite Ads × 15% − target margin)

Take off the shipping you charge and round up to your usual price ending. With a target margin of 0, the same formula gives your break-even price.

Margin isn't markup. A 25% margin means a quarter of the money the buyer pays is profit. Doubling your cost (a 100% markup) can leave far less than that once postage and fees come out.

Worked example: chocolate chip cookies by the dozen

A made-up home bakery. One batch makes 36 cookies and they sell by the dozen. The batch:

IngredientIn the recipeBought asCost
All-purpose flour2¼ cups (270 g, 0.595 lb)5 lb for $4.29$0.51
Baking soda1 tsp1 lb for $1.29$0.01
Salt1 tsp26 oz for $1.49$0.01
Unsalted butter1 cup (227 g)1 lb for $4.99$2.50
Granulated sugar¾ cup (150 g)4 lb for $3.99$0.33
Brown sugar¾ cup (165 g)2 lb for $2.79$0.51
Vanilla extract1 tsp2 fl oz for $6.99$0.58
Eggs, large212 for $3.49$0.58
Chocolate chips2 cups (340 g)12 oz for $3.99$3.99
Batch of 36$9.02

The grams come from 120 g a cup for flour, 200 for sugar, 220 for brown sugar, 227 for butter and 170 for chocolate chips. The rest of one dozen's cost:

Cost of one dozenAmount
Ingredients: $9.02 ÷ 36 × 12$3.01
Labour: 50 min a batch at $18 an hour = $15.00, ÷ 3 dozen$5.00
Packaging$1.85
Overhead: $82 a month ÷ 60 boxes$1.37
Cost per dozen ($0.94 a cookie)$11.22

The bakery charges $9.95 shipping and pays $10.40 postage. Etsy Ads take 5% of sales, about 1 order in 10 comes from Offsite Ads, and the target margin is 25%.

The price: ($11.22 + $10.40 + $0.45) ÷ (1 − 0.065 − 0.03 − 0.05 − 0.10 × 0.15 − 0.25) = $22.07 ÷ 0.59 = $37.41 for price plus shipping. Less the $9.95 shipping, $27.46 is the lowest price for 25%, or $27.99 rounded up. Break-even is $22.07 ÷ 0.84 − $9.95 = $16.33.

Checked at a price of $28:

One sale at $28 + $9.95 shippingAmount
Price + shipping paid by the buyer$37.95
Cost per dozen−$11.22
Postage−$10.40
Transaction fee, 6.5%−$2.47
Payment processing, 3% + $0.25−$1.39
Listing renewal−$0.20
Etsy Ads, 5%−$1.90
Offsite Ads: 15% on 1 order in 10−$0.57
Profit$9.80
Margin: $9.80 ÷ $37.9525.8%

Every figure is worked from unrounded amounts, so a column of rounded ones can be a cent off. $28 clears the 25% target, but not by much: if butter goes from $4.99 to $7.49 a pound, the dozen costs $11.64, the margin at $28 falls to 24.7%, and the lowest price for 25% rises to $28.17. Re-price when an ingredient you use a lot of changes.

Selling to a café instead, at 60% of retail ($16.80, no Etsy fees, no postage), the same dozen makes $5.58, a 33.2% margin on the wholesale price.

Selling food made in a home kitchen is covered by your state's cottage food rules, which differ on what you may sell, how it's labelled and whether it can be shipped. Check yours before you price for shipping.

The spreadsheet

My Recipe Cost & Bakery Pricing Calculator does this for up to 40 products. You list your ingredients by the pack you buy (5 lb of flour, a dozen eggs), type each recipe the way you bake it (2.25 cups flour, 1 tsp salt, 2 eggs), and the cost of every line fills in, converted through its units table. Add the yield and pieces per pack, and it works out the cost per pack and per piece, the lowest price for your margin and a rounded suggestion, and marks your own price PASS or FAIL. It also compares five prices, checks a wholesale price for cafés and shops, and shows the sales a month that cover your fixed costs. Etsy's US fee rates are filled in and editable. The cookies above are its example data. It's an .xlsx file for Excel, Google Sheets, Apple Numbers and LibreOffice.

Other pricing guides