White Hat Harbor

How to work out reseller profit

The sale price isn't what you made. A flip's profit is what's left after the platform's fee, the shipping label and what the item cost you, and the year's profit is what's left after your supplies, subscriptions and the miles you drove to find it all. This page gives the formulas for profit and ROI per item, days to sell, sell-through and inventory turn, and works one flip and one year through. It's the method my Reseller Spreadsheet uses.

Cost of goods: what the item cost you

Cost basis = what you paid + the sales tax and any shipping to get it to you. For a lot of identical items, divide by the number of units for the cost per unit; a mixed lot needs splitting by your best estimate of each item's share. An item you got free has a cost of $0, which is why ROI can't be worked out for it (any profit counts as a win).

Keep the cost of what's still on your shelves too. That's inventory at cost: money you've spent that hasn't come back yet.

Profit and ROI on one sale

Profit = sold for + shipping the buyer paid − the label you paid for − platform fees − cost of goods.

ROI = profit ÷ cost of goods. 100% means you doubled your money: an item that cost $10 made $10 after every fee and the label.

ROI is the useful measure for resellers, because what you're risking is the money you spent buying. A 300% ROI on a $2 shirt and a 40% ROI on a $50 lamp tell you different things: the shirt turned a little money into more, the lamp tied up a lot for a modest return. A target ROI, such as 100%, gives you a rule for what to buy: pass on items that can't reach it.

Platform fees

Most selling fees fit one rule with a few numbers, and it's worth writing each platform's down:

Some platforms have the buyer pay for the label, others leave it to you. Promoted or boosted listings, category exceptions and fees on sales tax sit outside the basic rule, so when you have the order page, use the actual fee it shows. Platforms change their fees: check each one's current fee page rather than an old figure.

Days to sell, sell-through and inventory turn

MeasureFormulaWhat it tells you
Days to sellSale date − purchase dateHow long your money sat in an item. Compare it by source and category.
Sell-throughUnits sold ÷ units boughtHow much of what you buy actually sells. Low sell-through means money stuck on shelves.
Stale itemsItems still on hand after a set number of days, such as 90What to re-price, re-list somewhere else, bundle or donate.
Inventory turnCost of goods sold over a period ÷ average inventory at cost in that periodHow many times your stock sells through in that period. Higher means the same money is working more often.

Mileage and expenses come off the year

Sourcing trips, mailers, tape, a label printer, a crosslisting subscription and a booth fee are real costs, but they don't belong to one item. Add them up for the year and take them off the profit from your sales:

Net profit = profit from sales − business expenses − business miles × the mileage rate.

For 2026 the IRS standard mileage rate for business is 72.5 cents a mile from 1 January, raised to 76 cents from 1 July. Log each trip's date and miles as you go; what you can deduct, and how, is a question for your tax preparer.

Worked example: one flip

A puffer jacket bought at a thrift store on 29 August 2026 for $13.99 plus $1.12 sales tax, and sold on 3 October 2026 for $48 with $8.50 shipping paid by the buyer. For the example, say the platform's rule is 10% of the price and the shipping, plus $0.30 per order (an example rule, not any one platform's).

The jacketAmount
Sold for$48.00
Shipping the buyer paid$8.50
Shipping label−$8.50
Platform fee: 10% × ($48 + $8.50) + $0.30−$5.95
Cost of goods: $13.99 + $1.12−$15.11
Profit$26.94
ROI: $26.94 ÷ $15.11178.3%
Days to sell35

Against a 100% ROI target, it passes. Run the same jacket through a platform that takes 20% of the price and has the buyer pay the label: the fee is $9.60, profit $23.29 and ROI 154.1%. Comparing what you'd keep on each platform at the same price, before you list, is quicker than finding out after.

Worked example: one year

The Reseller Spreadsheet's example business, a made-up part-time reseller, as of 15 October 2026: 49 items sold this year for $2,712.95 plus $194.25 in shipping charged, and a profit from sales of $1,563.77 after fees, labels and cost of goods. Then the year:

The year so farAmount
Profit from sales$1,563.77
Business expenses (supplies, software, a label printer, a booth)−$661.00
Mileage: 548 sourcing miles at the IRS rates−$405.38
Net profit$497.39

Expenses and mileage took more than two-thirds of the profit the sales showed. Its sell-through is 64.1%, with 26 units on hand at $325.88 cost and 4 items past 90 days.

The spreadsheet

My Reseller Spreadsheet keeps all of this in one file. Log what you buy, with what you paid plus tax and shipping, for up to 500 items; when one sells, pick its SKU and platform, and the fee comes from that platform's rule (or type the actual fee). Profit, ROI and days to sell fill in, marked PASS or FAIL against your target ROI. Platform Compare runs one item at one price through every platform and ranks what you'd keep. Fee rules for eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, Vinted, Etsy, Facebook Marketplace and local sales are filled in from their published US rates and editable. It also tracks expenses by Schedule C line and sourcing miles, and its Dashboard shows sell-through, inventory on hand at cost, stale items and your best and worst sources. It shows sell-through and days to sell rather than a turnover ratio. It's an .xlsx file for Excel, Google Sheets, Apple Numbers and LibreOffice.

Other guides